I am Rabbi Yehoshua Ben Karcha.  Did you ever think about the order of the paragraphs of Shema?

Shema, the first paragraph, is from Devarim chapter 6.  V'haya Im Shamoah, the second paragph, is from Devarim Chapter 11.  But then Vayomer, the third paragraph, is from back in Bemidbar Chapter 15! 

Actually, the order makes lots of sense.

First, we must accept that there is a Hashem, who has commanded us to love and obey Him.  That's what we do in the first paragraph of Shema.

Only once we do this can we say we accept the mitzvot.  That's what we do in the second paragraph when we talk about the rewards for obeying the mitzvot (and, G-d Forbid, the punishments for not).

The third paragraph talks about the mitzvah of tzitizit.

This only applies during the day, not night.  So, it goes last.

Find out more about Rabbi Yehoshua Ben Karcha by clicking HERE.

QUESTION: What is Rabbi Yehoshua Ben Karcha's question?  What is his answer?  If you are a Fuchs Mizrachi School student, click here to e-mail me your answer.

Would you like a challenge question?  The Gemara gives an additional answer.  CLICK HERE to try to figure it out!

back to the beginning of Chapter 2, Mishna 2

back to the Mishna Brachot homepage

back to www.fuchsmizrachi.org